Florida Patent, Trademark & Copyright Attorneys | Call 954-452-0033
(954) 908-6291
Available 24/7
Serving Inventors Throughout
the United States & Worldwide
Florida Patent, Trademark & Copyright Attorneys
Call UsEmail Us
blogs
May 7, 2023
John Rizvi, Esq.

Artists Who Used AI To Create Their Signature Work The Raises The Stakes In The War Between Human And Machine.

Read Full Post
[rank_math_breadcrumb]

Recently, I talked about graphic novelist Kristina Kashtanova. Their signature work, Zarya of the Dawn, features a nonbinary character (that is to say, someone who rejects conventional gender pronouns in favor of the gender-neutral “they/them” pronoun scheme), making their way through a postapocalyptic Manhattan. The work's copyright was partially rejected by the US Copyright Office because the illustrations which made up the book were created with the use of AI.

However, Kashtanova, who not-at-all-coincidentally identifies as nonbinary and uses they/them pronouns like the titular Zarya, has raised the stakes, vowing to test the limits and lines of where human ingenuity and creativity intersect with artificial intelligence under current US law and precedent.

But what will the Copyright Office do with this new onslaught, and what outcomes are most likely as the law scrambles to keep pace with the burgeoning technology?

What’s the Argument?

Kashtanova argues that if ANY human creativity or thought went into a piece of art, even if it’s generated by AI, then that art should, by definition, be eligible for copyright protection, as the Copyright Office stated in their original granting of an all-encompassing trademark.

The Copyright Office begs to differ, however, on the basis that a human’s input into an AI system does not grant the user anything more than the most superficial control over the final product, and therefore cannot qualify as “human authorship,” which is an essential component of assessment of an artistic work’s qualifications for copyright protection.

Per the Copyright Office, if Kashtanova had disclosed at the outset that they used the AI program Midjourney to generate the art for Zarya, which is now required as a matter of course in the aftermath of this mess, then the art which makes up such a crucial part of the overall story would not have been approved.

While Kashtanova retained copyright to the actual storyline and its arrangement, the art itself was held to be invalid and unprotectable under existing copyright laws. This makes Kashtanova the first person in American history to have copyright protection for AI art taken away, but that doesn’t mean Kashtanova isn’t fighting back.

To prove their point, Kashtanova has used a number of different AI programs, including one that allows artists to upload their own original creations and then edit and modify them using prompts fed into the AI interface. The program, known as Stable Diffusion, took one of Kashtanova’s sketches and generated a thoroughly haunting result, as you can see in the image at the top of this article.

More to the point, Kashtanova believes that beginning with actual human-generated art, rather than a series of prompts to refine a result, will meet the minimum human creativity requirement of the Copyright Office for copyright protection.

So What’s the Problem?

 So what’s the problem?

Among other things, there’s currently no clear-cut bright-line test to determine whether a work is eligible for copyright protection other than the “human authorship” requirement.

For example, a gorilla painting a banana, while awe-inspiring, is not copyrightable because a gorilla is demonstrably and fundamentally not human. When AI is thrown into the mix, everything is up for grabs.

This creates yet another series of problems, because if an AI program can be considered to be a legitimate author, it stands to reason that the creators/programmers of the AI in question should therefore have as much interest in the copyrights to a work as the stated creator.

Because AI (or its creators and programmers), not being a human intelligence in its own right, cannot at this time or in the eyes of the law be equally argued to be just as much a “creator” as the person filing for the copyright to a given work, the output from an AI program cannot be copyrighted.

Kashtanova’s argument that art generated through AI using human-conceived and human-executed prompts is still worthy of copyright protection turns that thinking on its head.

While the US Copyright Office is notoriously resistant to change, it is possible that if Kashtanova can demonstrate a more collaborative, rather than iterative, approach to developing art based on human concepts using AI, it might move the goalposts closer to the middle, where AI-generated art can be protected as long as there is clear evidence of human iterative control over the final outcome.

This is the key element that was seen to be lacking in Kashtanova’s original copyright.

However, the Problems don’t Stop There.

Let's say Kashtanova can prove their point to a level that the Copyright Office has no choice but to rewrite the rules (and failing Congressional or judicial intervention in the matter). If the Copyright Office affirms that AI-generated art is copyrightable given a minimum acceptable threshold of human ingenuity and intervention, there is still the question of how long it would take for owners or programmers of AI modalities to line up in the courts and sue the very authors who used the artwork created by their programs for royalties and other considerations. In the real world, you could measure that turnaround with an egg timer.

It doesn’t take a legal mind on the scale of F. Lee Bailey to foretell the traffic jams in the courts if those floodgates were opened, never mind the billions of dollars at stake for AI innovators and the people who use and profit from their innovations.

scale of F. Lee Bailey to foretell the traffic jams

 

The whole situation only becomes muddier when you consider the host of lawsuits against AI platforms like ChatGPT and Stable Diffusion for having been “trained” on copyright-protected works that were accessed through Google and other platforms.

By the logic of these suits, the very fact that the AI platforms’ training happened using content that the initial creators never intended or even conceived could or would be used in such a way automatically breaches their copyrights, where such can be proven. Even more damning when it comes to the “pure” arts, such as music, photography, and graphic design, the AI programs had to be trained using real-world, existing art.

The underlying assertion is that training AI programs on existing art isn’t like a college kid sketching a Bart Simpson doll in art class for a grade. These two events share a superficial similarity in that both mimic previously existing art as a matter of necessity. However, one (the art student’s output) is not intended to be passed off as an original creation except insofar as the human being behind the pencil replicated the doll, successfully or otherwise. The other (AI-generated content) cannot help but be evaluated as the net result of the human’s input PLUS a plethora of other influences which cannot be properly pinned down, analyzed, or evaluated, and thus whose antecedents cannot be satisfactorily traced or vetted.

The Bottom Line

Whether Kashtanova’s campaign to narrow and blur the boundaries of where human ingenuity and AI intersect will be successful is an open question at this time. It’s going to take years or even decades for the law to catch up to current innovations, never mind the ones lurking just beneath the near horizon.

However, Kashtanova’s arguments will be difficult, if not impossible, to dismiss as anything less than seminal in the ongoing war between human innovation and AI “creativity”...and will likely play a key role in how the courts, lawmakers, and the general public perceive AI-created art in the future.

This will certainly be one to watch, as no matter how Kashtanova’s arguments are perceived by the US Copyright Office and the courts, they’re sure to earn themselves a place in the history (and law) books!

© Copyrights 2024. The Idea Attorneys (The Patent Professor®). All Rights Reserved.
The information in this blog post (“post”) is provided for general informational purposes only and may not reflect the current law in your jurisdiction. No information in this post should be construed as legal advice from the individual author or the law firm, nor is it intended to be a substitute for legal counsel on any subject matter. No reader of this post should act or refrain from acting based on any information included in or accessible through this post without seeking the appropriate legal or other professional advice on the particular facts and circumstances at issue from a lawyer licensed in the recipient’s state, country, or other appropriate licensing jurisdiction.
The Idea Attorneys

10394 W Sample Rd #201,
Coral Springs, FL 33065, United States

(954) 908-6291https://ideaattorneys.dev.bestseocompanytampa.com/

Related Services

About Us

At the law offices of John Rizvi, P.A. - The Idea Attorneys®, we have dedicated our practice exclusively to securing and preserving the intellectual property rights of our clients, including patent, trademark, copyright, trade secret, unfair competition, and franchising matters.
© Copyrights 2024. The Idea Attorneys (The Patent Professor®). All Rights Reserved.

Services

Copyright Law 
Protecting Trademark Rights 
Trademark Law 
Patent Law 

Our Patent Attorneys & Agents

Marina Acosta 
Brittini Thacker 
Cristina Bautista 
Jonathan Bloch 
Francisco Castro 

Get in touch

Hours of Operation

Available 24/7

Follow Us

Florida Patent, Trademark & Copyright Attorneys | Call 954-452-0033
© Copyrights 2024. The Idea Attorneys (The Patent Professor®). All Rights Reserved.
The information you obtain at this site is not, nor is it intended to be, legal advice. You should consult an attorney for advice regarding your individual situation. Contacting us does not create an attorney-client relationship.
Slot demo https://mooc.unesa.ac.id/usutoto-4d/ slot online slot online akurat77 Demo Slot Pg Toto 4D https://wiki.clovia.com/ Slot Gacor Gampang Maxwin Slot77 Daun77 Daun77 slot thailand Daun77 slot77 4d Usutoto situs slot gacor Usutoto Usutoto slot toto slot Daun77 Daun77 Daun77 Akurat77 Akurat77 Perkalian 1000 Anda pemula lakukan trik ini di mahjong Pola mahjong ways modal dikit Anda sering rungkad lakukan trik ini Cara ledakin mahjong ways Pakai pola terbaru menaklukkan mahjong ways Sering Kalah di Mahjong Ways Luar biasa pak lele bocorkan mahjong ways Sosok crazy rich mahjong ways Strategi profit mahjong ways Akurat77 Akurat77 MBAK4D MBAK4D DWV99 DWV138 DWVGAMING METTA4D MBAK4D MBAK4D MBAK4D METTA4D DWV99 DWV99 MBAK4D MBAK4D MBAK4D SLOT RAFFI AHMAD METTA4D https://aekbilah.tapselkab.go.id/toto4d/ https://aekbilah.tapselkab.go.id/spaceman/ METTA4D METTA4D METTA4D demo slot MBAK4D METTA4D MINI1221 https://www.concept2.cz/ https://berlindonerkebab.ca/ togel malaysia sabung ayam online tototogel slot88 MBAK4D MBAK4D DWV138 METTA4D
Topui88 Topui88 Topui88 Topui88 Topui88 Topui88 Topui88 Topui88 Topui88 Topui88 Apakah Aplikasi Penghasil Uang Sugar Rush Masih Worth It Dalam Menghasilkan Uang Di Tahun 2025 Inilah Ulasannya Scatter Hitam Bukanlah Ilusi Raih Scatter Hitam di Olympus Sekarang Juga Sulis Penjambret Handal yang Gak Nyangka Berhenti Berbuat Jahat Karena Dapet Jekkpot 768 Juta di Fortune Tiger Aroma Sedhap RTP Lagi di Pucuk Sugar Rush Menjadi Primadona Bulan Ini Ingin Profit Besar Simak Rahasia Taruhan Terbaik agar Bisa Menyesuaikan RTP Live dan Menghindari Kekalahan Besar di Fortune Tiger Lelah Karena Menahan Puasa Malah Diberi Jekkpot 109 Juta di Wild West Auto Semangat Lagi Bang Anto Spin Mahjong Wins 3 di Warkop Gas Modal 35K Bisa Jadi 15 Juta Kopi Gratis Sepanjang Tahun Perang Sarung Jelang Sahur Lebih Baik Main di Sugar Rush Super Gachor Sudah Pasti Maxwen Cek Caranya di Sini Cegah Agar Tidak Rugi Mahasiswa USU Racik Pola Turun Wild Berjejer Turun Terus Menerus Live RTP Malam Ini Ungkap Teknik Paling Ampuh yang Membuktikan Keunggulan Mahjong Wins 3 Melawan Olympus di Ranah Kasino Online Terbaik topui88 topui88 topui88 topui88 topui88 Strategi Unggul Meraih Maxwin di Mahjong Wins 3: Teknik Jitu yang Mengubah Modal Jadi Profit Maksimal! PG Soft Gates of Olympus 1000: Game Online Unggulan untuk Meraih Keuntungan Besar dan Cuan Maksimal dengan Mudah! Topui88 Tawarkan Kemudahan Maksimal: Live RTP Mempercepat Setiap Spin dan Hasilkan Maxwin Instan! Sweet Bonanza: Lebih dari Sekadar Permainan, Ini Wadah Ambisi Menangkan Cuan Maksimal! Ungkap Seluk Beluk Topui88: Strategi PG Soft dengan Scatter Hitam yang Menggebrak dan Bawa Kemenangan Besar! Sudah Terbongkar Jurus Pamungkas Mode Blue Scatter Diamond Mahjong Energy Mengubah Nasib Menjadi Juragan Dalam Sekejab Bukan Sekedar Teori Mahjong Wins 3 Sedang Masuk Fase Maxwin Pola Zig Zag Jadi Rahasia Scatter Berjatuhan Tiada Henti Beberapa Spin Permen Langsung Meledak Saldo Meroket Tanpa Rem Mahjong Wins 3 Hadirkan Fenomena Naga Scatter Ganda Bang Suhen dari Terkejut Jekkpot Saat Jam 2 Pagi Modal Recehnya Jadi Ratusan Juta Gila Pemuda Ini Coba Mahjong Wins 3 Tengah Malam dan Scatter Langsung Gachor Membongkar Rahasia Scatter Merah Starlight Princess Bikin Cuan Ngalir Tanpa Henti Setiap Hari Taklukkan Brighton Man City Siapkan Taktik Jitu Mahjong Ways MU Menang Besar Amorim Sebut Setan Merah Seperkasa Mahjong Ways Susunan Pemain Everton vs West Ham Prediksi Skor dengan Formula Mahjong Ways Everton Hindari Kekalahan Lewat Gol Menit 91 Jake O Brien Sukses Susun Combo Mahjong Ways Pemain Timnas Kumpul di Jakarta Siap Atur Formasi ala Mahjong Ways 2 Sebelum ke Australia Menakar Peluang Manchester United Bisakah Setan Merah Raih Jackpot Mahjong Ways di Liga Europa Real Valladolid vs Celta Vigo Pertarungan Sengit Sylla dan Gonzalez Menuju Kemenangan ala Mahjong Wins 1-2 Milik Marquez Bersaudara Combo Sempurna ala Mahjong Ways di Kualifikasi MotoGP Argentina 2025 Ambisi Bayern Munchen Tak Terbendung Siap Menyapu Bersih Lawan dengan Taktik Mahjong Wins Al Nassr Vs Al Kholood Ronaldo Buka Skor Tapi Akhirnya Kehilangan Combo Mahjong Ways Setelah Deretan Kekalahan, Pemuda Ini Berhasil Membalikkan Nasib dan Meraih Maxwin Jutaan di Topui88 Mau Untung Besar? Intip Strategi Taruhan Unggulan Topui88 untuk Optimalkan RTP Live dan Cegah Kerugian Besar Bongkar Rahasia Pola Sakti Maxwin di Topui88: Kobol Medan Ungkap Strategi Buy Spin dan Live RTP yang Otomatis Menjamin Cuan Besar Kekayaan Instan Turun-temurun: Strategi 'Scatter Pitongwan' di Sweet Bonanza Buktikan Jackpot Terus Mengalir Sultan Bongkar Rahasia Cuan Maksimal: Dalam Beberapa Putaran Mahjong Ways 2, Kemenangan Miliaran Mengalir Deras Bulan Ini, Intip Rekomendasi Game PGsoft Paling Gacor: Strategi Ampuh untuk Raih Keuntungan Maksimal Eksklusif di Topui88: Temukan Surga Bermain Olympus 1000 dan Capai Keuntungan Fantastis Tanpa Repot Sweet Bonanza Pecahkan Batas Pengganda 1000 Kali: Ungkap Strategi Topui88 untuk Meraih Kemenangan Spektakuler yang Mengguncang Dunia Kilat Petir Spektakuler di Olympus 1000: Pengganda Seribu yang Mengantarkan Kemenangan Fenomenal dan Tak Terduga Bersiaplah Menjadi Sultan: Ungkap Rahasia Banjir Wild Emas di Mahjong Wins 3 untuk Meraih Kemenangan Luar Biasa Topui88 Topui88 Topui88 Topui88 Topui88 Topui88 Topui88 Topui88 Topui88 Topui88 Maxwen Mudah Diakses Strategi Bettingan dan RTP Live yang Memimpin Kemenangan Wild Bandito Proffesor UI Racik Trik kemenangan Mudah di Mahjong Wins 7 Zodiak Beruntung di Sugar Rush Raih Kemenangan Maksimal di Tahun Ular Inovasi Spin RTP Naik Turun di Lucky Neko Strategi Cerdas untuk Menang Berturut Turut Teknik Anti Ribet Mahjong Wins Buddha Strategi Live RTP untuk Pemain Profesional agar Untung Maksimal dengan Jackpot Konsisten di Jambi Trik Baru Auto Profit Tanpa Henti Strategi Baru Menang Besar di Starlight Princess Pola RTP Live Akurat 2025 Bantu Pemain Raih Maxwin Lebih Cepat dan Mudah Bingung Sesaat Dikira Kesalahan Server Tapi Pemain Ini Malah Panen Scatter Hitam Bertingkat Raih Kemenangan Rp150 Juta Lebih di Mahjong Wins 3 Serunya Sweet Bonanza Pragmatic Peluang Jekkpot Super Besar Menanti Siap Siap Panen Kemenangan Besar dan Sensasional Kejutan Pertengahan Bulan CEO PG Soft Persiapkan Hadiah Spektakuler Pola Scatter Hitam Mahjongways untuk Masyarakat Medan Rahasia Jam Ghacor Gates of Olympus Terbongkar Kini Saatnya Anda Menyambar Kesempatan Emas Meraih Hadiah hingga Rp225 Juta Cuma Dalam Waktu Singkat Dijamin Modal Kecil Bisa Berubah Menjadi Keuntungan Maksimal CEO PG Soft Menyajikan Prediksi Akurat Dalam Dunia Starlight Princess di Indonesia Scatter Hitam Sweet Bonanza Bisa Bikin Kaya Master Agus Berikan Bocorannya Untuk Pemain Asal Medan Shio Kucing Jepang dan Lucky Neko Pola Scatter Baru untuk Keberuntungan Besar di 18 Maret 2025 Bagaimana Topui88 Memprediksi Tren Scatter Hitam Digital yang Akan Mempengaruhi Kehidupan Sosial Di Semarang Scatter Mahjong Wins 3 dengan Pemberkatan Warisan Pola Scatter Naga Langit Sangat Gampang Menang Jekkpot Mengoptimalkan Teknologi RTP Live untuk Gaya Hidup Lebih Sehat dan Produktif Di Mahjong Ways Fenomena Scatter Hitam Mahjong Wins 3 Jadi Peluang Bisnis Rahasia Anto dari Makasar Tingkatkan Omzet hingga 500% Topui88 Membantu 1200 Masyarakat Jambi Beradaptasi dengan Tren RTP Live Digitalisasi Global Mengapa Starlight Princess Begitu Digemari Simak Alasan di Balik Popularitasnya dan Strategi RTP Live Bermain yang Efektif Mahjong Sensasi Strategi Baru yang Mengubah Pengalaman Gaming di PG Soft Buktikan Keberuntunganmu di Bulan Ramadhan: Mahjong Wins 3 Hadirkan Maxwin Instan, Rasakan Sensasi Kemenangan Puncak Dua Fakta Luar Biasa: Karyawan Jaksel Cetak Jackpot Lucky Neko Beruntun, Raih Jutaan Rupiah di Topui88 Bongkar Taktik Rahasia Mahjong Ways 2: Strategi Unggul yang Menggandakan Keuntungan Hingga Ratusan Juta dan Merombak Sistem Ekonomi Starlight Princess X1000: Terobosan Meta 2025 yang Menghipnotis Pecinta Game dengan Sensasi Tak Terlupakan Tolak Kecurangan Bandar: Mahasiswa Bongkar Trik Anti-Settingan untuk Menang Mudah di Game Online Terungkap! Pola Strategis Andalan Profesional Kobol Buktikan Dapat Meraup Kemenangan Maksimal di Sugar Rush 1000 Ungkap Pola Sakti Topui88: 5 Strategi Unggulan yang Bikin Bandar Kaget dan Hantarkan Jackpot Besar di Mahjong Wins 2 Salah Satu Member Jadi Sorotan: Modal Minim, Pola Cai Shen Wins Hantarkan Kemenangan Besar Bukan Rekayasa, Ini Bukti Nyata! Mahasiswa Bandung Cetak Maxwin Rp288 Juta di Wild Bounty Showdown Berkat Timing Sempurna Topui88: Rahasia Menghasilkan Cuan Berlimpah yang Bikin Semua Pemain Tersenyum Lebar Ungkap Rahasia Tersembunyi Jackpot Starlight Princess 1000 X25000: Strategi Teruji Menembus Batas Menuju Kekayaan Instan di Topui88! 5 Teknik Unggul dari Topui88: Rahasia Meningkatkan Penghasilan Maksimal dengan Bermain Sugar Rush yang Sedang Hits Ungkap Jejak Misterius Mahjong Wins3 Bareng Mantan Admin PUSAT: Scatter Hitam Pukau, Jackpot Rp200 Juta Menanti! Kisah Spektakuler: Pelajar Berani Menghadapi Tantangan Mahjong Ways dan Meraih Keberuntungan Seumur Hidup dengan Keajaiban RTP Live yang Mengejutkan! Bersiaplah Menjadi Sultan Otomatis: Mahjong Ways 2 Uji Keberanian, Hanya yang Bermental Baja yang Bisa Raih Kemenangan Teknik Multi-Fungsi Unggul: Menangkan Sweet Bonanza 1000 dengan Bantuan Robot Cheat Pragmatic untuk Mendulang Keuntungan Maksima Game Online Terfavorit di Tanah Air: Gates of Olympus 1000, Mesin Keberuntungan yang Melejitkan Cuan! Bongkar Misteri Pola Pistachio di Mahjong Ways Topui88: Strategi Unggul untuk Memperbesar Peluang Menembus Jackpot Maksimal! Dalam Sekejap, Kaya Raya: Mahjong Ways2 Tampilkan Sensasi Jackpot Maksimal yang Mengubah Hidupmu! Kalimantan News: Google Perkenalkan Aplikasi Engine Freespin Starlight Princess 1000, Membuka Era Baru Hiburan Digital! Mahjong Wins 3, Game Online Penuh Berkah: Cicilan Hutang Terbayar Lunas Berkat Kemenangan Spektakuler Capai Kejayaan Instan di Wild Bounty Showdown: Rasakan Sensasi Kemenangan Besar yang Membuat Anda Terpukau Bongkar Tabir Rahasia: Strategi Eksklusif dari Admin Kasino Online untuk Meraih Jackpot Besar di Starlight Princess 1000 Ungkap Rahasia Emas: Strategi Unggul Menaklukkan Queen of Bounty dan Meraih Jackpot Maksimal Rahasia Unggul Mafia Mayhem: Nikmati Permainan dengan Tenang dan Konsisten untuk Meraih Keuntungan Optimal Buktikan Keajaiban! Bermodal 25 Ribu, Sweet Bonanza Menghadirkan Maxwin Spektakuler untuk Kemenangan Luar Biasa Bongkar Teknik Rahasia Cai Shen Wins: Strategi Unggul yang Wajib Dicoba untuk Meraih Kemenangan Spektakuler Buktikan Keberanianmu! Rebut Kemenangan Maksimal Tiap Saat dan Raih Hadiah Spektakuler di Topui88 Panduan Ultimate Menguasai Game Paling Gacor di Situs Ternama: Rahasia Strategis untuk Mencetak Jackpot dan Menorehkan Kemenangan Fantastis Mahjong Ways: Gerbang Menuju Kemakmuran Luar Biasa! Cerita Inspiratif Pemuda yang Mengukir Kejayaan Lewat Jackpot Spektakuler Raih Pola Unggul dan Live RTP Gacor di Permainan Online: Menangkan dengan Mudah Tanpa Modal Besar, Siap WD Belasan Juta! Mahjong Depo Receh: Raih Winrate Fenomenal Seharian Penuh Belum Coba Gates of Olympus? Sayang Banget, Bro! Kuak Strategi Kemenangan di Topui88, Buruan Simak Tetap Santai dan Tersenyum: Raih Jackpot Mudah di Gates of Olympus untuk Rezeki Nomplok! Trik Rahasia Pemain Pro: Pilih Waktu Main yang Tepat di Mahjong Ways, Jackpot Hadir dalam Sekejap! RTP Meroket di Mahjong Ways PG Soft: Wild & Scatter Tumpah Ruah, Jackpot Makin Mudah! Raih Maxwin di Casino Online Terbaru: Bocoran Time Perfection untuk Kemenangan Pasti Tiap Hari! Topui88 Unggul dalam Daftar Pembagian Scatter Emas di Mahjong Ways Bulan Ini—Buktikan Sendiri Kehebatannya! Karyawan Mall di Medan Panen Jackpot 200 Juta di Gates of Olympus Menjelang Buka Puasa, Berkat Teknik Time Perfection! Intip Teknik Jitu Memaksimalkan Scatter di Mahjong Wins 3: Strategi TOPUI88 untuk Kemenangan Tanpa Batas! Rahasia di Balik Jekkpot Fantastis Pemain Topui88 Raih Rp2 Miliar dengan Perkalian x5.000 di Sweet Bonanza Benarkah RTP Live Jadi Faktor Penentu Modal 49K Bisa Jadi Ratusan Juta Pemain Pemula Spin di Mahjong Ways dan Jekkpot Beruntun Hujan Scatter Tanpa Henti Strategi Rahasia Suhu Agus Terbongkar Teknik Jitu Menurunkan Scatter Raksasa di Laughing Buddha Siap Panen Cuan Tanpa Henti Anto Sky Kembali Beraksi Kali Ini Berhasil Temukan Pola Baru di Gates of Olympus Scatter Beruntun Hasilkan Maxwen Besar Rahasia Double Scatter Mahjong Wins dengan Pola Eksklusif Bawa Pemain Bandung Raih Rp 185 Juta Strategi Dari Kaisar Tantai Santai Tapi Ampuh Menang Maxwen di Starligh Princess Cuan Besar Mudah Didapat Auto Banjir Scatter Setiap Hari DogeCoin Umumkan Mega Kolaborasi dengan Scatter Emas Topui88 Wild Mahjong Wins Cetak Rekor Wallet Gede Profit Ratusan Juta Bukan Sekadar Mitos Jam Gacor Sugar Rush Terungkap Scatter Makin Sering Muncul dan Cuan Mengalir Deras Tanpa Henti di Bulan Ini Hasil Maksimal Secara Konsisten Pancingan Pola Arahan Mimin Cantik Ini Auto Bikin Turbo Spin Kamu Bisa Turunin Scatter Di Mahjong Ways Trik Jitu Agar Wild Di Mahjong Wins 3 Lebih Lama Gunakan Pola Choco Hold Untuk Menjaga RTP Tetap Stabil Biarkan Scatter Wild Emas Menari di Putaran Starlight Princess untuk Profit Maksimal yang Bikin Dompet Tebal Dari Modal Receh Jadi Sultan Warga Semarang Ungkap Teknik Celestial Spin di Mahjong Ways 2 yang Jarang Diketahui Mengapa Gates of Olympus Menjadi Perbincangan Hangat di Komunitas Gamer Bekasi Developer Angkat Suara Soal Scatter Hitam Mahjong Ways Benarkah Fitur Ini Terlalu Gampang Bikin Pemain Menang Besar Pernyataan Resmi Justru Picu Spekulasi Baru Lagi Kisah Nyata Sultan Scatter Abu Abu Pria Biasa Menang Mahjong 12 Hari Berturut turut Berkat Scatter Hitam Keberuntungan Luar Biasa Ini Terbukti atau Ada Strategi Rahasia di Baliknya Tips Maxwin Sweet Bonanza Paling Ampuh 2025 Terbukti 99 dari 100 Pemain Berhasil Rahasia Pola Taruhan dan Timing Scatter Bawa Keuntungan Luar Biasa Mau Coba Terobosan Baru Mahjong Wins Pragmatic dengan Spin Beraturan Serta Dana Tambahan dari Aplikasi Penghasil Saldo Strategi Terbukti untuk Raih Maxwin Pemain Ungkap Pola RTP Live di Sweet Bonanza dan Sugar Rush untuk Cuan Beruntun Gak Paham Lagi Dah Cara Cerdas Manfaatkan Penuh Info RTP Live Mahjong Ways Terbaik Bisa Cuan Parah Mahjong Wins 3 Kembali Mengguncang Dunia Kejutan Multiplikator Super Besar Turun Tanpa Diduga Saatnya Maksimalkan Keuntungan Pengumuman Resmi dari Asosiasi Gaming Dunia: Game Topui88 PGSOFT Mencapai Persentase Kemenangan RTP yang Luar Biasa dengan Jackpot Terbesar yang Mengalir Deras Tanpa Henti, serta Menyuguhkan Kejutan Spektakuler yang Berpotensi Mengantar Anda Menuju Puncak Kekayaan dengan Modal yang Sangat Minim! Ungkap Keajaiban Pola RTP Live yang Memukau dengan Memulai Taruhan Kecil di TOPUI88 dan Nikmati Kejutan Maxwin yang Tak Ternilai, Menjamin Pintu Kemenangan Besar dalam Setiap Permainan! Ungkap Rahasia Formula Sakti yang Sedang Viral di Karo untuk Meraih Kemenangan Super Gacor serta Nikmati Pembagian Jackpot Puasa Eksklusif dari Topui88 Slot! Rasakan Keajaiban Fitur Terbaru di Mahjong Wins 3 yang Menyajikan Koneksi Unggul dan Berpotensi Mengantarkan Puluhan Juta Hanya dengan Taruhan Seribuan Saja! Kolaborasi Strategis antara Pragmatic dan TOPUI88 Menjadi Kunci Utama Keberhasilan Para Pemain Tanggerang dalam Meraih Puncak Kemenangan!